top of page

Is joining a Healthcare Sharing Ministry a better choice over insurance?

Updated: Apr 16


The landscape of healthcare options has expanded beyond traditional insurance plans, with alternative models like Healthcare Sharing Ministries or HealthShare for short, are gaining attention. In this blog post, we'll explore the concept of HealthShare Ministries and weigh the pros and cons against conventional health insurance, helping you make an informed decision about your healthcare coverage.

Understanding HealthShare Ministries:

HealthShare Ministries are faith-based, non-profit organizations where members pool their financial resources to cover each other's medical expenses. These ministries operate on shared principles emphasizing community support, shared responsibility, and a commitment to a healthy lifestyle.

Pros of HealthShare Ministries:

  1. Cost Savings: One of the primary attractions of HealthShare Ministries is the potential for cost savings. Monthly contributions (similar to premiums) are often lower than traditional insurance premiums, making it an appealing option for those seeking affordability.

  2. Community and Shared Values: HealthShare Ministries foster a sense of community among members who share similar faith values. This communal support can be emotionally uplifting, creating a unique healthcare experience.

  3. Exemption from ACA Requirements: HealthShare Ministries are exempt from Affordable Care Act (ACA) regulations, providing members with more flexibility in choosing coverage options. This exemption may result in fewer mandated coverages, giving members the freedom to select services that align with their needs.

Cons of HealthShare Ministries:

  1. Limited Coverage: HealthShare Ministries might not cover certain medical services or pre-existing conditions. Some offer a phase in period or waiting period before they share in medical needs. Medical sharing decisions are subject to the community driven ministry guidelines, which may vary between organizations.

  2. Not Regulated Like Insurance: HealthShare Ministries are not regulated as insurance, which means they lack the oversight and additional costs that get added to your insurance rates. This oversight was mandated because of poor decision making and lack of transparence often plagued by insurance companies. It also means consumers need those protective measures that traditional insurance plans are required to adhere to because of past misdeeds. This can lead to potential risks for members, especially if their ministry is acting like an insurance company.

  3. Non-Guaranteed Payments: Unlike insurance policies that “guarantee” coverage for eligible expenses, HealthShare Ministries must operate differently than insurance, hence they must claim sharing is on a voluntary basis. There is no contractual obligation to pay medical bills, if there were they would be considered insurance and then subject to insurance regulations and increased rates. The sharing of medical expenses is contingent on the members’ adherence to membership guidelines and their understanding that it is not insurance. Members usually understand how HealthShare differs from insurance, and that's why they join. Be aware and know that it may not be a fit for everyone.

Comparative Analysis:

When deciding between HealthShare Ministries and traditional insurance, it's crucial to consider individual needs, preferences, and risk tolerance.

  1. Cost Considerations: HealthShare Ministries offer cost savings, but it's essential to evaluate the coverage provided and potential out-of-pocket expenses. Traditional insurance plans may have higher premiums but could offer more comprehensive coverage. You do the math, (Premium x 12) + Deductible + max out of pocket = Total Value for your dollar.

  2. Coverage Requirements: Assess the specific medical services you need and compare them against what each option offers. HealthShare Ministries might have limitations, especially for pre-existing conditions and certain treatments. Review the Membership Guidelines for more information.

  3. Risk Tolerance: Consider your comfort level with the uncertainty associated with HealthShare Ministries. Traditional insurance plans provide a contractual “guarantee” of coverage, offering more predictability in times of need, but at a higher cost!


Choosing between HealthShare Ministries and traditional insurance is a personal decision that depends on factors such as financial considerations, coverage needs, and individual values. It's crucial to carefully review the terms and conditions of both options, weighing the pros and cons to determine which aligns best with your healthcare priorities and lifestyle. Consulting with one of our HealthShare Coaches can also provide valuable insights to guide your decision-making process. We understand this isn’t for everyone, and that’s okay!

13 views0 comments


bottom of page